I ordered my correct shoe size in black - I love it...my toes have just enough space from the edge of the sandal. You do have the option to adjust it around the ankle and the vertical piece that fits in-between your toes. I love that the bottom of the sandal is not slippery even after putting a little lotion on my heels, the piece that fits between your toes is made flat so that it doesn't rub or aggravate the skin. This is a sandal that will last me at least 2 summers in Las Vegas for sure. It is a very affordable and well made.